Analysis, takes, and signals from the ownership coin frontier.
-
01
-
02
-
03
-
04
-
05
-
06
-
07
-
08
-
09
The Big Picture
September felt like the calm before the storm.
There were no major new raises on MetaDAO. Futardio completed four small launches, HiveBits, plus three Spark-backed ideas, LFOWN, ACCRUE and PREDICT, all of which hit their funding targets. Attention is turning to Futardio's upcoming relaunch and rebrand, which could reset the launch pipeline heading into Q4.
Decision market activity on the other hand was much higher. 18 proposals resolved and 17 passed, even though volume halved to $368K from August and just 91 wallets traded. More decisions were made by fewer people.
This issue's Call looks at how teams can turn ownership into a growth tool, using Avici as an example. Our Signals cover launch liquidity and the proposals that are going unnoticed and what we will be doing to address it.
The Call
Ownership rewards are worth testing where teams can connect them to measurable commercial activity.
Ownership Coin Incentives
Ownership coins give teams a way to connect customer incentives with ownership in the organization. Teams with recurring revenue can test whether rewarding product use, referrals, and other contributions with ownership increases retention and profitable activity. The case for these programs depends on whether the additional business they generate exceeds their cost.
Ownership coins are valuable because they represent a claim on the economics of an organization. Loyalty programs exist to align individual behavior with the company’s success. Rewarding loyalty with ownership can expand the holder base while providing incentives and recognition to the people who help create that success.
Ownership and Loyalty
American Airlines runs AAdvantage, a loyalty program that rewards members for flights, credit card spending, and other activity. Shareholders are not directly part of that system. Owning AA stock does not contribute to a customer’s status, mileage earnings, or travel benefits.
In March 2021, American raised $10 billion through financing backed by AAdvantage, demonstrating the financial value of its loyalty business. An ownership coin could connect these currently separate systems. Having ownership could qualify customers for benefits, while their spending and other activity could earn additional ownership.
Japanese airlines connect ownership and patronage more directly. JAL and ANA issue domestic flight discounts to eligible shareholders. JAL also grants additional coupons to qualifying long-term shareholders. JAL describes its program as a marketing tool intended to encourage repeat travel and increase demand on flights with excess capacity. These programs provide an existing example of using ownership benefits to encourage product use.
So what behavior would improve the business and can ownership help produce it?
What Onchain Ownership Changes
Public companies often have an incomplete view of their shareholders, which makes connecting ownership with customer activity more difficult. Public blockchains make wallet balances and transfers directly observable. With a verified link between a wallet and a customer account, teams can use that information to determine eligibility for benefits.
A wallet address does not automatically identify a person or customer. One user may control several wallets, hold coins through an exchange, or use separate wallets for ownership and product activity. Any ownership-linked benefit needs a way to verify and maintain those connections.
Once those links exist, an issuer can combine three things:
- Whether an account owns the coin
- How stable that ownership has been
- Whether the account uses or contributes to the product
Ownership Incentives
Teams can reward customers with ownership, offer benefits to existing holders, or combine both approaches. The incentives could target the following behaviors:
- Patronage - Turn holders into paying users and reward activity that produces a margin.
- Distribution - Pay for verified referrals or sales that bring valuable customers to the product.
- Participation - Reward shipped work, useful data, or proposal/decision market participation that improves the organization.
- Holding duration - Test whether benefits tied to sustained ownership improve customer retention and profitable product use.
Each program needs a defined budget, predefined targets, and an evaluation period. The additional profit it generates should exceed the cost of rewards and administration. Users attracted primarily by rewards may still participate but their activity needs to meet the same profitability test.
Using Avici as an Example
This is purely for illustration. Avici card spend and card revenue are measurable. Avici reports gross interchange revenue typically equal to 1.4% to 2% of card spend, before sharing revenue with infrastructure partners. The amount available for rewards depends on the margin remaining after partner payments and other variable costs. A program could test whether ownership rewards increase profitable spend and customer retention.
- Eligibility - A verified Avici user links a wallet holding a qualifying $AVICI balance. This design targets holders who could become active card users. To reach customers who do not already hold $AVICI, the program could offer a base reward without an ownership requirement and an enhanced rate for qualifying holders.
- Reward - An illustrative base reward is 0.5% of eligible net card spend, paid in $AVICI. Longer continuous ownership could raise the rate modestly, for example to 0.625% after 180 days. The actual rates must be set from margin and the expected increase in activity.
- Funding - Approve a fixed quarterly budget through a proposal. Rewards could be funded with $AVICI purchased using USDC or newly minted. Value allocated tokens at their market value when assessing program costs.
- Controls - Exclude refunds, chargebacks, or other categories that produce no margin and delay settlement until transactions are final.
- Measurement - Track incremental spend, profit after rewards and program costs, 90-day retention, the share of holders who become users, and new holders who retain a balance.
At a 0.5% reward rate, rewards would consume ~25% to 36% of Avici’s reported gross interchange revenue. The program must generate enough additional profit to cover rewards on all eligible spending, including spending that would have occurred without the incentive.
Some Other Options
- Tenure-based fee rebates - An account that maintains a qualifying balance of $AVICI for 180 days receives lower product fees. Measure whether improved retention and activity cover the cost of the rebates.
- Verified referral rewards - Pay a holder only after a referred customer reaches a revenue or retention milestone. Fund the reward from the customer acquisition budget and compare it with other acquisition channels.
Final Thoughts
Ownership rewards are worth testing where teams can connect them to measurable commercial activity. Programs can encourage holders to use the product, refer customers, or make useful contributions, while giving customers a way to earn ownership through their activity.
For Avici, that could mean a card spending program evaluated on additional contribution profit and customer retention. Sustained growth in the holder base would be another useful outcome. Programs that deliver these results after accounting for reward costs would demonstrate a practical role for token economics in ownership coins.
Ecosystem Ledger
Decision Markets
September was the busiest month yet for MetaDAO decision markets, with 18 proposals resolved and 17 passing on $368K of volume. But most of that activity came from a handful of markets and just 91 unique wallets. A summary of consequential proposals is covered below.
Volume was $18.9K across 159 trades from 21 wallets. It split almost evenly at 51% Pass-aligned, while 63% of traders leaned Pass. The proposal cleared the -3% threshold by ~4.9%, one of the tighter results among the month's larger markets.
The 18-month cliff on Rip Cars' performance package is removed. For the first 18 months, unlocked tokens can be sold subject to a rolling 30-day cap of $100K or 5% of the package. Proph3t co-authored the proposal, and it is the first live test of MetaDAO's push to give app builder founders faster access to liquidity.
Only $186 traded, across 4 trades from 4 wallets, and all of it was Pass-aligned. The proposal cleared its 0% threshold by ~3.5%.
Paystream winds down. Protocol-controlled PAYS is burned, and ~37.8K goes into a liquidation vault redeemable at $0.0267 per PAYS, a 35.6% recovery against the $0.075 ICO price. The DAO LLC is terminated, and the IP is released open source under Apache-2.0.
Volume was $96.4K across 305 trades from 18 wallets, with 80% Pass-aligned. The proposal cleared the -3% threshold by ~18.1%, one of the most decisive results of the month.
The DAO withdraws its entire single-sided Meteora position, and ~900K SOLO returns to the treasury ahead of the public USDv launch. Trading now concentrates in the ~$3M futarchy AMM. The returned SOLO cannot be deployed without a separate governance vote.
This was the month's largest market, at $143.2K across 1,192 trades. It came from only 8 wallets, 88% of them repeat traders. 57% of volume was Pass-aligned, and the proposal cleared the -3% threshold by ~10.8%.
MetaDAO can now use tokens it earned from fees for three purposes on behalf of launched projects: loans to market makers, exchange listings and DeFi integrations. Market-maker retainers require a minimum $50K USDC earnings carve-out. This is permission only, but it turns market making into a DAO-level service and a direct answer to "why launch on MetaDAO?"
Volume was $22.9K across 153 trades from 6 wallets. 68% of volume and 86% of traders were Pass-aligned, and the proposal cleared the -3% threshold by ~8.6%.
Umbra can spend up to $250K over 45 days buying UMBRA through Jupiter recurring capped at 5% below NAV ($0.1986 vs. NAV of $0.2091). UMBRA was trading ~18.5% below NAV when the proposal went up. Acquired tokens go to the treasury for v2 incentives and cannot be resold or used as market-making inventory.
Volume was $7.0K across 9 trades from 6 wallets, with 63% Pass-aligned. The Pass and Fail TWAPs finished just 0.05% apart, so the proposal passed on the -3% team-sponsored threshold, clearing it by ~3.1%.
Credible moves $500K from its treasury to use as a float to fund same-day payouts. The principal is to be returned at the end of a 3-month term.
Volume was $61.8K across 466 trades from 9 wallets, the month's third-largest market, though one wallet placed 21+ trades. Pass-aligned volume was only 55%, but the Pass price finished ~19% above Fail and cleared the -3% threshold by ~22.4%, one of the most decisive results of the month.
Rip Cars can mint and sell up to 12.9M new CARS over 30 days, mostly through OTC deals priced at the higher of the 24-hour TWAP or $0.05, capped at $1.5M in proceeds. Any unsold tokens are burned.
Also resolved in September
There were proposals from Umbra, Credible, and Omnipair to convert a portion of DAO treasury held in USDC to Solomon’s USDv ($300K, $250K and $130K respectively). All three of them passed.
Valuation Analysis
In this section we highlight one organization in the MetaDAO ecosystem and share a valuation analysis. This is not financial advice or investment recommendation.
Credible Finance
What backs each token - As of Oct 1 CRED was trading at $0.74. The DAO treasury holds $3.30M, and NAV/AS was $0.31. The other $0.43 ($0.74-$0.31) is what the market is paying for the payments business itself, putting CRED ~133% above its treasury backing.
What the business earns - According to its Dune dashboard, Credible processed $191M in September. That is up 4.4% on August's $183M and its largest month so far. Credible keeps about 0.20% of what it processes so ~$382K in September so far and $2.38M over the last 12 months.
How the price compares - One way to look at CRED valuation is dividing the market value by yearly revenue. In order words, this is how many dollars investors pay for each dollar of revenue.
We start with Adjusted Supply which is the 10.52M CRED that trade freely today, leaving out tokens still locked for investors and the team. At $0.74 that is a market value of $7.78M ($0.74 × 10.52M CRED).
- Last 12 months: $7.78M ÷ $2.38M of revenue = 3.3x. The market pays about $3.30 for every $1 Credible earned over the past year.
- September's pace (annualized): $7.78M ÷ $4.59M (September × 12) = 1.7x, or about $1.70 per $1 of revenue if September's volume held for a year.
- Closest listed peers (dLocal, Flywire): 2.9x to 3.0x, meaning their shareholders pay about $2.90 to $3.00 for every $1 of the past year's revenue.
Looking at the last 12 months CRED is priced in line with its closest listed peers on past revenue. If growth continues at September’s pace, the current valuation looks attractive. On a fully diluted basis, counting every CRED including locked tokens ($16.84M), the same measures are 7.1x and 3.7x above the peer range. The difference between the two readings is the locked supply. Investor tokens vest over three years and the team's tokens unlock only if CRED reaches 2x to 32x its ICO price, so the fully diluted figure is the one to watch as those tokens release.
CRED at $0.64 Against Listed Payments Companies
Spotlight: Dual Mint
Overview
DualMint is raising $227,500 on Star.fun to buy 200 claw machines in Shenzhen shopping malls, and $PLAY holders get paid from their activity. The raise runs from October 1-8.
How It Works
$PLAY represents a 20% equity stake in a BVI company, set up through Bedrock, that holds legal title to all 200 machines. The operator runs the machines and every machine pays the company each month. DualMint takes a 10% fee, and the rest goes to $PLAY holders in USDC. The target is 12% a year at launch, rising towards 15% as more machines are activated.
Why It's Worth Watching
$PLAY applies the ownership coin model to real-world cash flows. Holders get legal title to the assets, and the structure is built so they're paid first. The verification is the most interesting part.
Every play is counted on the machine's own board and tied to an onchain machine ID through Peaq. Chainlink then reconciles each month's machine data against bank receipts and the operator's report, and a NAV attestation is posted onchain every month. This is the kind of continuous, verifiable financial reporting most teams say is too hard.
DualMint also has a track record. Since May 2025 it has financed 1,300+ machine-backed positions, including laundromats in Vietnam and air conditioning units in Hong Kong and has paid depositors every month for 16 months. It reports 15.72% realised net returns and no operator defaults.
Signal vs. Noise
Solomon's withdrawal of ~900K SOLO leaves 14 MetaDAO ownership coins still holding the single-sided Meteora position they launched with and for most it has gone dormant. Seven still hold their full 900K seed amount, with no USDC, and all trade below ICO price. Nine pools together hold ~$620K of tokens against just $62 of USDC, so they offer no bid today and become a programmed sell wall the moment price recovers toward the ICO price. Credible ($98K USDC), Rip Cars ($22K USDC) and Laso ($8.3K USDC) show the pool working as designed. We could see more teams move liquidity out of their Meteora positions and back to the DAO.
There is no standard today for how teams announce proposals. This month, several community members pointed out that new proposals went almost unnoticed. A proposal that few people see is decided by whoever is watching and the outcome reflects that thin crowd, not the market's view. As teams use decision markets for bigger decisions, quiet proposals become a governance risk.
What would fix it? Alerts that don't depend on each team remembering to post. That means automatic notices for every decision market, delivered to the channels holders already use, with a direct link to trade.
The 01R website and Telegram alert bot automatically posts every new decision market to the 01R community; including alerts throughout the decision lifecycle (initiated, pre-TWAP, TWAP, etc.). In the future, any community can add a bot to their own group. It will contain a link to trade the proposal on the MetaDAO website and analyze it on 01R.
The Noise: NAV valuation creates an incentive to build up a treasury rather than spend it on distribution.
Our Take: NAV is not the whole valuation. It is one lens, and the most useful thing it shows you is a “floor” and/or a holder's pro-rata claim on the treasury. Ownership coins give holders an enforceable claim on the treasury, so NAV is what the business is worth if it stopped operating. Everything above it is the market pricing the business itself. NAV doesn't reward hoarding at all, it shows whether spending is creating value. If a team deploys capital into growth and the premium widens, the market likes the spend. If the token sits below NAV, holders are saying the treasury is worth more than what's being built with it.
The Noise: Reporting is friction a team with a publicly listed token can't justify yet. The accounts are messy, accountants are expensive, and if the numbers are early or weak, publishing them only hurts.
Our Take: Teams should report because the market prices silence anyway, and it prices it at the worst case. Every decision market, buyback and valuation in this ecosystem runs on financial data (or lack thereof), so without reporting, traders are guessing and holders fill the gap themselves. Early teams need a baseline to show progress against, and struggling teams need credibility most.
Around the Space
↗ MetaDAO: Beyond the Token Sale
Delphi shares its MetaDAO growth thesis which revolves around scaling many smaller launches rather than chasing large VC-style rounds.

↗ Hunter Simmons: the problem with MetaDAO
Hunter argues MetaDAO currently selects for teams that cannot raise traditional VC and should move “up market” to more mature pre-token projects. There was no shortage of feedback on the topic.
The problem with @MetaDAOProject in its current form is that it selects for teams who can't raise VC.
— Hunter Simmons | Imperial (@ImperialAttila) September 29, 2026
If I were @metaproph3t I would spend all my efforts moving "up market" and talking with more mature teams who haven't launched a token yet.
This is the only problem that…
By the Numbers
Value
(Adjusted Supply Method)
to NAV